种群

剧情很有意思，主角人物演技很好，尤其是男主，换别人也演不出杰洛特的味道，个人感觉没有有些人说的剧情这么离谱，猎魔人的剧情安排也十分合理，就是感觉第一季时间线安排很美国风格（个人感觉也有些美剧是这样拍的），中国人会看不习惯，这也是导致有些人对这部剧评分低的原因，还有对于一些游戏党玩过游戏后，对里面的人和剧情已经有自己的看法了所以当选角不满意时，也可能对这部剧打低分（个人认为主演选角都不错），对于原著党来说，这部剧想贴近原著，又想和原著有区别，所以会穿插一些别的怪物，之类的剧情，但是这些剧情编剧在采访中提到，主要来源东欧的神话故事里（个人认为穿插的没问题），可能没有自己读小说的那种情怀，所以也会有人给它打低分。

总得来说，电视剧可能有自己的想法，也有自己的表达方式，猎魔人绝对是区别于权利的游戏的一部神作（目前认为），但是猎魔人电视剧是肯定不能完全满足游戏党和原著党的情怀的，毕竟人家电视剧明明白白的说了改编于小说，而且游戏呢，它自己也有自己的运行方式，所以电视剧也是会和它们不同。

这不妨碍猎魔人这部剧好看（以上纯纯个人观点，我真的觉得它很好看）以下个人第一季剧情梳理，希望对各位有帮助

申明：巫师3含DLC全通，但小说没看。

先说优点：1.动作场面确实不错，大量和怪物打斗的场面完成得非常出色，作为一部动作片是过瘾的。

但是贯穿全剧的最终Boss，每次出场都颇为故弄玄虚，云里雾里的，算是小失误。

2. 第一集改编得确实不错，有黑童话那味道，故事相对独立，算是一个优秀的把人骗进去宰的材料。

3. 如果巫师3玩家来我这里想和我一起喷“好莱坞选角的zzzq”那我不奉陪，我觉得肤色不是问题，选角上，Ciri，Yen和Triss的选角没有问题。

尤其是Triss这季妆造大大改良了，好看了不少。

而这季的新选角里老爷子和菲丽芭非常优秀，而迪胖被大大地美化了一把。

4. 优点这一栏，“亨利卡维尔”五个字值得单列并且大书特书他的好，以下省略一万字彩虹屁。

这剧的评分只有三星，剩下的两星是给亨利卡的。

话说回缺点，我最不满的在于，把人物性格和关系完全写崩了。

为了衬托Ciri的成长线，她身边所有人都有一定程度的扭曲，叶奈法会有背刺Ciri的想法，老爷子犹豫不决决断力连Ciri都不如，而杰洛特为了Ciri把剑拍椰奶脖子上的场面真的是让我翻白眼…最可怕的是，经过了这样的一个扭曲地调整，居然还有点自圆其说地圆回来了，但是格局小了很多很多。

猎魔人的世界里那么一点温暖善良的角落，那些可爱的人，都变得小家子气了。

凯尔莫罕在玩家心理的世外桃源感，就被打碎了。

第二季第一集开始我心情还挺激动的，到了艾斯卡尔便当开始觉得不对劲，后面从第五第六集开始多个人物全崩……醉了，编剧说他们改编自小说而不是游戏，那我可以接受人物选角上的各种和游戏冲突的地方，但是小说里也不是这样的人物性格啊！

这魔改真是让人不舒服。

得承认，第二季制作要精良一些，但在原著+游戏党看来，改编得一般……主要体现在：1. 编剧把短篇和长篇不同时间点的情节糅合起来，糅得不够妙，变成了一些很常见的流水剧情；2. 角色也都有些简化过度，杰洛特强行塑造成了霸道强者，表现出耍帅大于自省的感觉，其他角色的台词也在烘托杰洛特是最强的猎魔人，但原著和游戏里都没明确提过猎魔人之间的战力差，只是说杰洛特是入世最深的一个，此外杰洛特是一个谦虚并对世道和正义有很多自己思考的人，剧里表现出的只是喊口号。

希瑞的问题和杰洛特性质类似，原著中希瑞绝大多数时候都不知道自己的血脉和能力，剧里过早点出并且用这点顺手塑造一个成长中的年轻女性角色，还是口号成分多;3. 设定改动太大且漏洞多：（1）原作中没有火魔法是禁术的设定，而且编剧连这点都不自洽，猎魔人的伊格尼法印也算火魔法，那伊格尼有没有副作用？

（2）剧里法印的表现好像比正规法术还要强，但在原作里法印只是术士们都不屑提的最基础魔法。

（3）术士战斗力弱化，在原作中，术士中远距离打猎魔人跟玩似的，近战也有过吊打杰洛特的术士，大家都知道是谁。

（4）神殿祭司和术士无论是理念还是技术上都不是一个派别，剧里杰洛特让南尼克开传送门那里我差点没把头歪成九十度，祭司不会魔法，只能行使某种治愈或者诅咒的能力，传送是一种魔法，南尼克是绝对不会的。

能用魔法解决的问题术士几乎都不会用劳动解决，甚至晚会上鱼子酱都是法术变出来吃，所以术士不会动手做药水，一般只有祭司、乡村巫医、猎魔人、医者会做药水，看着特丽丝叶奈法在那鼓捣药瓶感觉很违和。

剧透警告⚠️ 19年的时候接触巫师三游戏，当时只打了主线没打dlc ，也是刚接触3a，更多只是玩着新鲜，剧情没看明白多少，也没深究。

今天下午看完了第二季的电视剧，感觉是越来越好看的。

尤其是第二季刚开始ciri开始训练的时候，还有最后一集ciri面对女妖创造的ciri和亲生父母在一起的幻境，不能自拔的时候，Geralt说“we belong together，you，us。

it is not perfect，but it is real”。

我也幻想过自己出生在更好的家庭会不会比现在更优秀，也沉浸在虚拟游戏里无法自拔。

但是再完美的虚拟世界和幻想也不能取代自己亲身经历过的不完美的现实。

无论是节奏还是剧情，都不如第一季。

本季重点是没有R级镜头，很少，相当少，没个床戏！！

打戏也很少，节奏不强，就很拖沓。

剧情就很突兀，突然这样突然那样，连贯性也不如第一季。

总之就是不精彩。

大部分就是在对白，没有很宏大的魔法场面，感觉是不是剧组缺钱了。

另外，找个漂亮的公主很难吗？

朝天鼻，老妈妈嘴，在中国这就是比较丑的了。

还老是拖后腿，成事不足败事有余，这个角色很不讨喜。

话说2年了我连女主角们和原著的颜值天堑都习惯了——好家伙S2直接剧情天崩了...敢情就靠性感大超在线宠女续着呗[擦汗]奈飞选角瞎就算了编剧也不能学学隔壁黄暴殴乜？？

虽然权游最后也崩了好歹撑到了S8啊...你这才S2就把IP直接埋土里了？？

依我愚见之后别展开白狼椰奶的感情线了...反正魔改了索性直接改白狼希里鬼父线吧...

整体感觉一般吧，太散了，很多好玩儿的支线剧情，但组合在一起并不那么像回事。

就像一个人五官都漂亮，但是组合在一起却平淡无奇。

最初几集坑挖得都很好，后面填得平淡没惊喜，难怪某著名剧评人说就第一集最好看。

这部最吸引我的坑是Yen失掉魔法了。

她上部最后“release your chaos”那里太震撼太强大了。

魔法对她太重要了，差点献祭Geralt的child surprise找回魔法。

最后他们一起打deathless mother那里，Yen主动做deathless mother的vessel, 然后魔法就回来了。

据说失掉魔法是因为火魔法侵蚀灵魂。

那么魔法最后咋回来的呢？

Yen的老师也一直说Yen心里一直有空虚，她试图用魔法来弥补，可是魔法也无法完全填充，所以空虚一直都在。

失掉魔法后Yen开发了一些不用魔法也能做的工作，比如教Ceri控制她的魔法。

也许在和Ceri相处的过程中她体验到单纯的美好？

在最后她以自己肉身向deathless mother献祭救Ceri的那一刻完成她和Ceri的联结，用爱战胜deathless mother，同时也是她也完成了自我救赎，于是魔法回来了？

Anyways, 据说书中并没有这一段。

某著名剧评人说这一段只是想说明没有魔法的Yan也一样可怕。

另一个就是Treiss会不会黑化？

她在Sodden战中被严重烧伤，身心都受到很大创伤。

她自己都还创伤未愈身心俱疲，而Ceri是超强大同时心灵的创伤不比Treiss轻，这个时候Treiss要看Ceri世代灵魂深处是什么真的是好主意么？

显然不是因为她没hold住。

不过可能也不能完全怪她，她觉得Ceri无非一个倔强的小屁孩，有啥难度，她大概没想到Ceri有那么复杂的背景那么powerful。

如果她意识自己创伤未愈不如平时强大，也许会有更好的办法来引导Ceri. 后来她回去跟Tissaia沟通之后意识到Geralt以为Yan死了才找她，她在Yan前也有自卑。

重创后无法自处，加上自卑，期待下一步他们怎么处理这种情绪。

Ceri这一条线就是一直神神叨叨的。

这个小女孩很要强的性格也真让人稀罕。

她看到帮她那一家人被fire fucker 烧死好让人心疼。

她说和自己沾边的人和物都会被毁掉，要多强大才能和这种认知和平共处啊！

这三个女性角色是“什么是强大？

不够强大怎么办？

”的一种注解。

至于这个剧，引某著名剧评人的一句话，他引的第一季中Geralt对Jaskier的评价，“a pie with no fillings”。

第二季的情节没有第一季凌乱，索登战役结束，叶妮芙失踪，杰洛特以为她已战死沙场，带着希瑞回到凯尔莫罕，途中杀死了吸血妖鸟，解除了纳威特的诅咒，猎魔人艾斯卡尔被树林矮妖感染操纵，差点杀死维瑟米尔，最终被杰洛特杀死，杰洛特发现矮妖与巨石碑有关；失去法力的叶妮芙被芙琳吉拉俘虏，在途中她们又被法兰杰茜卡率领的精灵抓住，三人又分别被不死之母蛊惑；被芙琳吉拉放走的叶妮芙救了要被处死的卡西尔一起逃亡，各方势力都想得到希瑞；希瑞在凯尔莫罕苦练技艺，特莉丝和维瑟米尔一起发现她的上古精灵血脉的作用，火术士里恩斯出场了；卡西尔回到尼弗迦德阵营，叶妮芙遇到吟游诗人亚斯克尔再次逃亡，在南尼克的神庙遇到了杰洛特和希瑞；法兰杰茜卡出生的小精灵被杀死，率领精灵报复人类，用法术杀死了众多人类婴儿；芙琳吉拉用法术杀死了反对她的尼弗迦德军官，迫使卡西尔结盟；被不死之母附身的希瑞，并从巨石碑引来了怪兽，重创猎魔人，关键时刻杰洛特稳住局势，抚平众人心绪，使得以痛苦和仇恨为食的不死之母法力减弱，叶妮芙想用牺牲自己方式让不死之母附身，从而解救希瑞，最终希瑞战胜了不死之母。

最后一集的最后时分，恩希尔皇帝出场，露出了真容，书第七部的悬念在剧第二季就揭开了。

总的来说，第二季的情节基本算是原创的了，我的原著算是白看了，那种感觉既失落又好奇，原创情节在逻辑、节奏和衔接方面并未超越原著，令人失望，于是失落慢慢地全面碾压了好奇，这剧在豆瓣上能得这么高的分，可能一大半是超人巨星光芒的功劳。

第二季比第一季更吸引人, 感覺回到魔戒的氛圍, 夠強,夠慘,夠狠, 而且整体的人/事/物都非常美, 故事分幾條支線, 都留下未知,当走到一起時,以為看到答案,沒想到謎中謎, 讓你情不自禁的想追下去看, 欧美的美學,充滿多次元的美感，每個角色都獨特,都美!此劇的特效高超, 人的造型經典華麗, 台詞不多,劇情是舖陳出來及演員演譯出來, 精彩好片,也是視覺的嚮宴.

Fuck it. I decided to compile a list of every change between Season 2 and Blood of ElvesHeavy spoilers for the books and Season 2!\---This is not all-encompassing. I'll forget some changes--Heaven knows the writers made enough changes. I'll also preface this by saying: This isn't a commentary on the quality of the season itself. It is simply a collection of the differences between the novel and the show.**Characters*** Voleth Meir is not in the books. Completely new character.* Geralt wouldn't use Ciri as bait in the books. Nor did he.* Ciri is never possessed by a witch.* Yennefer does not lose her magic in the books. * Yennefer never considers sacrificing Ciri for power. Nor does the opportunity ever arise.* Yennefer is not captured by Niilfgard in the books. * Instead, she is blinded following Sodden after taking a fireball to the face from Fringilla. She then spends lots of time in recovery, then--on Dijkstra's orders--tails and saves Dandelion from Rience. * No one ever thinks she's dead in the books either (Geralt worries that she died after Sodden, if I recall, but finds out rather quickly she's still out there after talking to Triss at the Sodden memorial)* Later in the series (Post Time of Contempt/Late Season 3 or early Season 4 by comparison), people suspect Yennefer of being a Nilfgaardian spy. But at no point does anyone suspect her of being a spy following Sodden.* The Stregobor stuff isn't a thing in the books. He's there, but plays no important role.* Vessemir wouldn't try to use Ciri's blood to create more witchers in the books. Nor would he ever allow Ciri to undergo the Trial. Nor would he let Eskel bring a bunch of hookers to Kaer Morhen* In the books, Dandelion is actively working with Djikstra and the Redanian Secret Service. This is removed in the show It is implied that Djikstra is funding Dandelion's sandpiper activities, though Dandelion doesn't seem to be aware of who he is working with. This is speculative on my part though. * Also in the books, Dandelion is not nearly as comedic as he was in Season 2. He is funny, but they seemed to lean into that aspect of him for Season 2. * This is more my interpretation, but in the books, Dandelion is far wittier than he is in the show. He certainly doesn't come across as the type to talk to rats in the book.* Djikstra is not a rambling drunk in the books (although I didn't find that to be a bad change. It was pretty interesting IMO).* I don't believe Istredd even appears in Blood of Elves* Francesa Findabar is *not* with the Scoia'tael in the books. By this, I mean she's not in the field with them, acting as their leader. * She is a member of the Brotherhood of Sorcerers, though she does harbor sympathies for their cause and occasionally meets with Scoia'tel leaders (Filavandrel, as an example). This relationship becomes relevant when she aids Niilfgaard during the Coup at Thanned* Fringilla Vigo does not become de facto leader of Cintra in the books. Instead, she fucks off to Niilfgard* Cahir is not captured by the Brotherhood following Sodden in the books. I don't even recall if he was at Sodden. As far as I recall, he traveled back to Niilfgard following the Fall of Cintra, and was imprisoned for failing to capture Ciri. We don't see him again for another two books after Sodden. * His execution plot-point never happened in the books. * Book Cahir is also not nearly as mustache-twirly-evil-villain as he is in the show. Cahir fans will know what I mean.* Tissaia is hardly a significant character in the books.* Rience is not a magical bounty hunter in the books. He's an almost fanatical follower of Vilgefortz in the books. * Rience is scarred in the show and books, but in the books, it's because Yennefer uses her magic to wound him as he's interrogating Dandelion.* Lydia Van Bredevoort does not develop her scars from sniffing a vial of elder blood in the books. Instead, her scars are a result of magical experimentation on Vilgefortz' orders, and her wounds are hidden with an illusion.* Eskel is not turned into a Leshen and then killed (as far as we know. He's not in the books for long.)* Vilgefortz and Tissaia are not a romantic thing, as far as I could tell. Nor are they really even partners. Vilgefortz is also the genuine champion of Sodden in the books. He does this to gain more authority in the Brotherhood. * Vilgy is also way stronger and smarter in the books then how he is depicted in the show. Also, Vilgy never says his classic line. This is a cardinal sin, imo.* Nenekke is an old and religious lady. She doesn't go around dropping f-bombs in the books.* Emhyr kept the fact that Ciri was his daughter a big secret in the books. Understandable, given his plans for her (**cough** Imperial Incest **cough**)* Jarre in the books is a bit of a geek, who is very clearly awkward around girls, and has a crush on Ciri. But he's also smart, and good-intentioned. The show reduces him to a dick joke.**Plot Points*** Except for Ciri's training, there is not a single fight at Kaer Morhen. Never. There is no Leshen, nor is there the centipede thing with the claws. There is no possession. * There are only four witchers at Kaer Morhen (Vessemir, Eskel, Lambert, and Coen) * At Kaer Morhen, Ciri trains and exercises. Eventually, Triss arrives (on Geralt's request) and instructs Ciri on the basics of magic, as well as the Elder language.* The plot point with Ciri's blood being able to make more witchers is not in the books. * Vesemir never collects her blood either. The thought of making more witchers is only ever entertained in the context of Ciri being raised as a girl vs. being raised as a witcher. But the mutagenic process itself/Trial of Grasses is never brought up.* In the book, Triss travels with Ciri and Geralt to the Temple. In the show, she doesn't. We don't see her get sick. * On the path to the Temple is when they run into Yarpen Zigrin again. This doesn't happen in the show. As a result, Ciri doesn't visit Shaerrawedd, and there is no fight with the Scoia'tael.* There is no fight at Melitele's Temple in the books. Never.* Yennefer does not travel to the Temple to kidnap Ciri and sacrifice her in the books. * In the books, Ciri and Yennefer stay at the temple for a while. Ciri learns more magic. * Yennefer is invited to the temple by Geralt after Geralt has already left. See the 'Dear Friend,' bullet point further down. * There is no reunion between Geralt and Yennefer in Blood of Elves. They reunite outside Gors Velen in the next book.* In the books, Rience does not find Ciri at the Temple. Instead, Geralt leaves Ciri in Nenekke's care to find Rience at Oxenfurt. * There is no Shani in the show. >:( * Phillipa does not help Geralt find Rience, nor does she help Rience escape: as she does in the books. * In fact, Rience doesn't meet Ciri till the Time of Contempt, which is the next book following Blood of Elves.* Dandelion doesn't sing at a tavern in Oxenfurt. He sings at Bleobheris, a sacred tree. * His Sandpiper plot is not a thing in the books. * Dandelion is not arrested in the books.* The elf and Cintra plot is not in the books. * There is a non-human uprising in the North in the books, led by the Scoia'tael, but they are not given Cintra as a place of refuge by the Niilfgardians. Instead, Niilfgard is suspected of funding and arming them behind the scenes to stoke instability in the North.* Francesca never gets pregnant. Nor does Emhyr commit infanticide against an elven baby in the books. * The notion that a pure-blooded elf hasn't been born in decades is also a Netflix invention. Elves have a much smaller window of time to get pregnant, but it still happens in the books. Avallach and Geralt talk about this in Tower of Swallow.* The magical politics is a thing in the books, but is very different from the magical politics in the show. Stregobor does not interrogate or harm Yennefer, and neither do Tissaia/Vilgy use that as an excuse to seize Council seats. * Instead, the magical politics in the book are concerned with the growing distrust between the Kings and their magical advisors * The meeting of the Kings at the end of Season 2 is the meeting of the Kings in BoE that puts the Mages on edge, and is used to justify the Conclave in Time of Contempt. However, Tissaia is at the King's meeting in the show, which is not the case in the book. No mages were invited to the meeting in the books.* When the Kings of the North meet, they do conclude it best to kill Ciri--so as to prevent her falling into Emhyr's hands (they don't want him to have a legitimate claim to the Cintran throne). However, the show cut the King's talk of war with Niilfgaard. * In the books, they believe a quick strike across the Yaruga could recapture Cintra, and deal a blow to the South. This conversation paves the way for the Second Great War, but does not happen in the show. * The show also leaves out the politics regarding Cintra's throne. Cordhingrer is visited by Geralt in the books, and they develop a plot to--essentially-- smear Calanthe's name and ruin her claim to the Cintrant throne, thus making Ciri's claim to the throne illegitimate. Thus, protecting her from the kings who want her dead for her political power.* Again, the Voleth Meir plot is not in the books at all. Instead, Blood of Elves focuses on Ciri's training and planting the seeds for future conflicts. * I.e. the Second Great War, the Coup of Thanned, Character's motivations to capture Ciri, etc.* The Monoliths are not a thing in the books.* The 'Dear Friend,' bit is in reference to letters exchanged by Yennefer and Geralt while Geralt is in Oxenfurt hunting for Rience. Geralt asks Yennefer to travel to the temple to train Ciri. Again, Geralt and Yen don't actually meet though.* In the books, Niilfgardians are depicted as something more akin to the Romans or English (Highly centralized government with progressive and aristocratic traditions and legal codes). In the books, they are not religious zealots. Though they are also not necessarily 'good' either.* Yennefer and Cahir never have a team-up in the books.* Tissaia does not recommend that Ciri be captured, nor does she suggest that anyone protecting her be captured as well. In fact, Tissaia's role in the show is dramatically overblown.* Ciri is not with Geralt when he meets Nivellen.* Istredd does not meet with Cordringer and Fenn in the books. Geralt does meet them to find information about Rience and Ciri.It's not an exaggeration to say that the *majority* of this season is different from the books. And not just sort of different, but drastically different. Hell, the last four or five episodes are fictitious (relative to the book canon (yes I know it's all fiction, please stop reminding me)) in nearly every way. At this point, I'm not certain where the story will go. For example, how will the Coup play out on Thanedd if Ciri won't be able to attend it? And if Ciri isn't at Aretuza for the Coup, then how will she be warped to the desert? And if she isn't separated from Geralt and Yennefer, then how will she meet up with the Rats?Obviously, they can still work these plots in, or at least, work in the *effects* of these plots, but the story will take a drastically different turn than the one the book tells.Note that this isn't necessarily a good or a bad thing, so long as it's done well. But there has to come a point when the adaptation is so drastically different from the source material, that I start to wonder whether it's truly an adaptation, or if it's a reimagining.